Skip to content
LokalMatch

Auto Insurance Brokers

Auto Insurance Brokers: directory of firms

Auto insurance is the one policy most American adults are legally required to carry, and it is the one most people buy on price alone. Each state sets its own minimum liability requirement, and those minimums were written to satisfy financial responsibility law rather than to cover a serious collision. Texas, for example, requires at least 30,000 US dollars of coverage for injuries per person, up to 60,000 per accident, and 25,000 for property damage.

Browse auto insurance brokers by city, and see what to check before you hire.

This kind of work is often limited to licensed or registered professionals. Ask for their licence or registration number before you share any details.

Directory only

LokalMatch doesn’t take requests for auto insurance brokers in the US and doesn’t pass your details to anyone. Firms are listed as a directory: compare them and contact the ones you choose directly. LokalMatch doesn’t recommend any firm.

Paid listings and paid requests aren’t switched on for this service in the US.

On this page

Liability pays the other party. It repairs their car and pays their medical bills when you caused the crash. It does nothing for you or your vehicle. The coverages that protect you are separate line items: collision, comprehensive, medical payments or personal injury protection, and the one people skip most often and regret hardest, uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage.

A broker who works several carriers can price the same set of coverages across companies and, more usefully, point out where the policy will not respond at all: delivery driving, a car kept at a different address, a named driver excluded from the policy. Those exclusions cause more denied claims than anything to do with limits.

State minimums and financial responsibility law

Every state sets its own required liability limits and its own rules for proving you carry them. The numbers are written as three figures: bodily injury per person, bodily injury per accident, and property damage. Texas requires 30,000 per person, 60,000 per accident and 25,000 for property damage, which is written 30/60/25. Other states are higher or lower, and a few allow alternatives to insurance such as a bond or deposit.

The minimum is a legal floor, not a recommendation. A single hospital stay after a highway collision can exceed a per-person bodily injury limit before anyone has looked at lost earnings, and once the limit is exhausted the balance is a claim against you personally. This is why an umbrella policy sitting above the auto liability limit is usually the cheapest protection in a household's insurance budget.

The coverages on an auto policy and who each one pays

  • Liability repairs the other driver's car and pays their and their passengers' medical bills and certain other expenses when you caused the accident.
  • Collision pays to repair or replace your own car after an accident, subject to your deductible.
  • Comprehensive covers your car for theft, fire, flood, vandalism and other causes that are not a collision.
  • Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage pays your medical and repair costs when the at-fault driver had no insurance or not enough, and it also responds in a hit-and-run.
  • Personal injury protection pays your and your passengers' medical bills and can cover lost wages and other non-medical costs; in Texas it is included in every auto policy unless it is rejected in writing.
  • Medical payments coverage pays medical bills regardless of fault, on a narrower basis than personal injury protection.

Legal minimum versus a limit that would actually hold

Compare two quotes honestly and you usually find that raising liability limits substantially costs far less than people expect, because the frequency of catastrophic claims is low while the cost of one is enormous. The premium curve is steepest at the bottom. Going from a state minimum to a materially higher limit rarely doubles the price.

Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage deserves the same arithmetic. It is the coverage that responds when the person who hit you carries the legal minimum and your injuries do not. Carrying high liability limits to protect other people while carrying low uninsured motorist limits to protect your own family is the most common imbalance on an American auto policy, and a broker who does not mention it is not paying attention.

Driving that your personal policy will not cover

  • Rideshare and food or parcel delivery with the app on, which most personal policies exclude and which usually needs an endorsement or a commercial policy.
  • Regular business use, such as carrying tools, samples or paid passengers, where a personal auto form was never designed to respond.
  • A named driver exclusion, where a household member has been removed from the policy by endorsement and is not covered at all if they drive.
  • A vehicle garaged at an address other than the one on the policy, including a car left with a student in another state.
  • Permissive use limits, where someone who borrows the car regularly should have been listed as a driver.
  • Racing, track days and intentional damage, which are excluded on essentially every personal auto form.

Deductibles, rating and the discounts worth having

Collision and comprehensive each carry a deductible, and raising them is the fastest lever on premium for a household with savings to absorb a small loss. The calculation is simple: work out the annual saving from the higher deductible and compare it against the extra amount you would pay out of pocket on the frequency of claim you realistically expect.

Rating varies by state and by carrier, and what one company weights heavily another ignores, which is precisely why shopping several carriers matters more here than in most lines. Ask about discounts that are actually available rather than advertised: multi-policy, multi-vehicle, telematics programs, defensive driving courses, good student status, and paid-in-full or paperless billing. Also ask what happens to the rate after one at-fault claim, before you make one.

Lapses, proof of coverage and SR-22 filings

A gap in coverage is expensive twice over. States enforce financial responsibility through registration and licence systems, so a lapse can mean fines, suspended plates or a suspended licence. It also moves you into a higher rating tier when you do buy again, because carriers treat continuous prior coverage as a rating factor in its own right.

After certain violations a state may require a filing, commonly called an SR-22 or in some states an FR-44, in which your insurer certifies to the state that coverage is in force. It is not a type of insurance; it is a certificate attached to a policy. Not every carrier files them, the filing usually has to stay in place for a set period, and cancelling the policy notifies the state automatically. Tell your broker up front if one is required.

Total losses, rentals and disputes after a crash

  • A total loss is settled at the vehicle's value, not at what you owe; gap coverage is what closes the difference on a financed or leased car.
  • Rental reimbursement is a separate coverage with a daily and total limit, and repairs routinely run longer than the limit allows.
  • Diminished value claims, where a repaired car is worth less than before, are recognised in some states and not others.
  • Aftermarket or recycled parts may be specified in the policy language, and the time to read that is before the estimate arrives.
  • Storage and towing charges mount quickly after a tow to an unfamiliar yard; tell the carrier where the vehicle is immediately.
  • Where the carrier's position will not move and you believe it is wrong, the complaint route is your state department of insurance.

Auto Insurance Brokers: frequently asked questions

What does my state actually require?

Every state sets its own minimum liability limits, expressed as bodily injury per person, bodily injury per accident and property damage. Texas, for instance, requires 30,000 US dollars per person, 60,000 per accident and 25,000 for property damage. Check your own state's department of insurance for the current figures, and treat them as a legal floor rather than as adequate protection.

Does liability coverage repair my own car?

No. Liability pays the other party when you are at fault: their repairs, their medical bills and certain other expenses. Damage to your own vehicle is covered by collision for accidents and comprehensive for theft, fire, flood, vandalism and similar causes. If you carry liability only, a single-vehicle accident is entirely out of your own pocket.

Do I need uninsured motorist coverage?

It is the coverage that pays your medical bills and repairs when the at-fault driver had no insurance or not enough, and it also responds in a hit-and-run. Given how many drivers carry only the state minimum, it is often the most useful line on the policy. Where it is optional in your state, ask for a quote at a limit matching your own liability limit.

Will my policy cover me while driving for a rideshare or delivery app?

Usually not. Most personal auto policies exclude use for hire, and that exclusion typically bites from the moment the app is on. Some carriers sell an endorsement that fills part of the gap, and the platform's own coverage generally applies only in certain phases of a trip. Tell your broker before you start driving, not after a claim.

What is an SR-22?

A certificate your insurer files with the state confirming you carry the required coverage, generally required after certain violations. It is not a separate kind of insurance. Not all carriers will file one, it usually must remain in force for a set period, and cancelling the policy notifies the state, which can suspend your licence or registration.

Should I raise my deductible to cut the premium?

Only if you could comfortably pay it tomorrow. Work out the annual saving against the extra you would pay per claim, and remember that small claims often cost more in future premium than they return. Raising the deductible and using the saving to increase liability and uninsured motorist limits is usually the better trade.

Sources

  1. Texas Department of Insurance: auto insurance guide
  2. NAIC consumer resources and state insurance departments
  3. NAIC: producer licensing

Written by the LokalMatch editorial team. Last reviewed September 22, 2026. How we write and check our guides

Find auto insurance brokers by city

California

Show 186 cities

Florida

Show 82 cities

Texas

Show 79 cities

What affects the fees auto insurance brokers charge

Fees depend on the work involved and how the professional bills. We only publish fee ranges when they’re backed by real LokalMatch data or reliable sources. Until then, here’s what usually changes the fee:

  • Scope and complexity of the work
  • How the professional bills: hourly, flat fee or retainer
  • Experience and seniority of the person doing the work
  • Deadlines and how urgent the work is
  • Third-party costs such as filing, registration or government fees

How to compare auto insurance brokers before you hire

  • Check that they are licensed or registered for this work where you live, on the regulator’s public register.
  • Look for experience with matters like yours, and ask who will actually handle your file.
  • Ask how they charge before any work starts, and get the terms in writing.
  • Compare two or three professionals before you decide.
  • Be wary of anyone who guarantees a particular outcome.

Questions to ask auto insurance brokers before you hire

  • Are you licensed or registered for this work, and with which body?
  • Have you handled matters like mine before?
  • Who will do the work, and who will I deal with day to day?
  • How do you charge: hourly, a flat fee or a retainer?
  • What is included in your fee, and what costs extra?
  • Will you confirm the scope and fees in a written engagement letter?
  • Do you carry professional liability insurance?

Licences and registration

This kind of work is often limited to licensed or registered professionals, and the rules depend on where you are. Ask which body they’re registered with, and check their status on that body’s public register before you hire.